A friend of mine was telling me a story about how he had a project that had $100,000 left in its budget. He and his team wanted to use it up, since the norm was if you didn’t use it, your budget would be cut by that amount the next year.
I asked what they wanted to spend the money on. He said, “USB video cameras.”
Then, I asked, “why?”
“Because we’ve rolled out a video capability to the company.”
Interested, I continued my questioning. “But don’t the laptops people use (and the company has already purchased) have a video camera already built in?”
“Yes, some of them do. We want to buy cameras for those laptops that do not already have a camera and to create a spare pool.”
Good recovery I thought, but I wasn’t quite done, so I asked “But isn’t everyone already on a list to get a laptop refresh, where they all eventually will have a laptop with a built in camera, making these USB ones obsolete?”
“Well, yes,” he said.
I was intrigued because I kept hearing about people putting a piece of tape or a post-it note over the laptop camera for fear they might be accidentally captured on video when they didn’t want to be, so further investment in it raised some red flags.
“Do you even know if people use the video feature? What’s the data tell us the usage patterns are? How many video sessions are you doing in a day? What are you going to do with all the cameras after the laptop refresh?”
I admit I was Feeling like Tom Cruise questioning Jack Nicholson in the movie “A Few Good Men”. He was at his breaking point.
“No. I don’t know any of that. No usage data. No trend analysis. No strategy post rollout. We just thought we should buy the cameras because the budget had room,” he said.
Needless to say, he didn’t buy the cameras. No business case, no understanding of the business problem he was trying to solve, and no data. Common sense prevails.
I think generally, most good intentioned people are action oriented. While not a bad thing, I think sometimes we make decisions without all the inputs. Other factors and incentives drive us to do things that perhaps we wouldn’t do in our own personal lives, but at work we can ignore some common sense questioning that can get us in trouble. If we all treated our work, or work decisions, like we were the owner of the company, my feeling is that different decisions would be made. I think it’s always a good exercise to stop ourselves and ask what business problem we are trying to solve.
In that context, we might just make different decisions.